
As I sit writing in my flat, looking out at the yellow-flowering tree just outside my kitchen, I find myself wondering how I might contribute to my work. But, does this make sense? A tree whose name I do not know, a kitchen (a space for cooking and eating) doubles as becomes a space to write. Perhaps this is where I want to begin: with what “I do not know”, with the seemingly ordinary things that invited us to look a little closer.
Perhaps “I don't know” was where it all began. I remembered learning how to roll a saree for archival storage. It seemed at first to be a very mundane, straightforward task: wear gloves, handle it carefully, look at their condition, ensure that the textiles were backed by acid- free paper, tyvek and then put away. There seems to be a method to do it, the eyes and hands certainly have to be attentive. Yet, when thinking about it now, what does it mean to learn how to roll a textile? What does this reveal about the larger system in which textiles are preserved? When is an archive finished, and how would we know that? How do we better understand the ecology of practice within standardisation and classification?
Before a textile reaches our hands and table, it was made, worn, preserved, then collected and acquired, transported, and identified. Once it reaches it is documented, examined, and rolled to be kept in an appropriate storage environment, with many systems of classification and then is given periodic attention. If they are to be exhibited, they must once again be retrieved, assessed, handled, perhaps travel for darning and then be prepared for display. Hence, a single textile that was rolled up is sustained by multiple decisions, material arrangements and acts of labour. Hence, rolling seems to have become a movement in a much larger practice of care, with the possibility of being studied in the future. While we make provision for the physical survival of textiles, they cannot necessarily guarantee the survival of memories and relationships associated with them.
This distinction becomes particularly significant when we consider the archive not simply as a repository of objects, but as an institution that produces and organises knowledge. Quoting Ann Laura Stoler (2008, p.20) “archiving-as-process rather than archives-as-things” helps one to consider archives as ways of doing. In her context, it is a review of colonial archives shaped by political anxieties and institutional practices, rather than as neutral storehouses of information. Yet, her approach offers a useful question for textile collection: how do the systems through which textiles are described, classified, and documented shape what can subsequently be known about them?
While cataloging, one records the textile material, dimension, technique, provenance, and year. But how do we accommodate the other histories that do not fit into these categories: the person who wore it, the circumstances of its everyday use and the relationship of its acquisition. Because what gets documented greatly shapes what can subsequently be known. This raised a question about the limits of archival care: what does it mean to preserve a textile when it is not always possible to preserve everything that makes it meaningful? Could this simply be because the information is missing, or does it reflect upon the established parameters within which what can be recorded as knowledge and who decided is considered legitimate
Arjun Appadurai's perception on the social life of things gives a different dimension to re-consider objects as they acquire their meaning through relation to social and economic circumstances. Textile does not possess a single, fixed meaning, its significance moves between households, marketplaces, ritual settings and collectors prized pieces. Who wore it when? Was it a gift? Its forgotten techniques, later give meaning to the textile. Hence, when a textile enters the archive, one set of relationships may give way to another. Its condition, rarity or historical significance. This does not necessarily mean that institutional preservation erases earlier meaning, rather the terms through which we are encountering them have changed.
Thus, an attempt has been made to understand these absences and ambiguous practices through Susan Leigh Star’s work on seemingly “boring things” that constitute infrastructure. Star and Karen Ruhleder (1996), conceptualised infrastructure as a fundamentally relational concept, arguing that it becomes infrastructure in relation to organised practices.
So, within a given cultural context, the cook considers the water
system as working infrastructure integral to making dinner. For the city planner
or the plumber, it is a variable in a complex planning process or a target for
repair: “Analytically, infrastructure appears only as a relational property, not as a
thing stripped of use. (Star & Ruhleder, 1996, p. 113) (Qtd. p, 380)
This relational understanding offers a useful way of thinking about textile and the infrastructure that sustains it. Archival practice depends on systems that often remain invincible until they fail, or interrupt the work they are meant to support. Storage drawers, the catalog, the available space, the allotted time for handling may not be understood as part of the textile, yet, they shaped the textile. Hence, what might initially appear to be a simple act of rolling becomes a part of the system of practices that are understood through doing. These ways become a main component on how textiles can be preserved and accessed. Hence, storage facilities, cataloguing procedures, conservation regulations and institutional resources all shape what an archive can accomplish. Their importance becomes apparent when textile can not be stored appropriately or when things become uncertain. Hence, archival care is a series of processes that are in continual negotiation among many stakeholders.
The nuances of these processes could be further examined through Shannon Mattern’s work on maintenance and care, which draws attention to the often overlooked labour through which objects, spaces and systems are sustained. Dusting the shelves, changing the light bulb, rolling the textile and maintaining the temperature often recede from view because it seeks to prevent deterioration and disruption. Archiving care takes place through repeated acts, and one should understand that maintaining the physical condition cannot sustain every piece of knowledge nor eliminate uncertainty.
Returning to the act of rolling textiles, I begin to consider how this might serve as a form of care. It may protect the textile, keep it intact and become a necessary moment within a larger process for who may encounter it in future. However, this raises the fundamental question on what care truly means? I find myself with more questions than answers. How do we remain attentive to limits of preservation? And how might we acknowledge uncertainty as part of caring and allow its classification to be revisited?
Some questions can be answered through established systems while others emerged only through experience. Perhaps this is one way of approaching textiles, to begin with what the hands were asked to do. It must have begun by learning how to roll a saree, but the task extends far beyond the act itself, opening up the wider consideration of what it takes to care for an object. So then, maybe to care for a textile is also to care for the gaps between what is known and what is unknown. Yet, it creates a space where the conditions are sustained in which histories can continue to be questioned, re-learned, and where possible, recovered.
What can be studied is always a relationship or an infinite regress of relationships. (Bateson, 1978, p. 249) (Qtd. Star, p. 379)

References
Appadurai, A. (Ed.). (1986). The Social Life of Things: Commodities in Cultural Perspective. Cambridge University Press.
STAR, S. L. (1999). The Ethnography of Infrastructure. American Behavioral Scientist, 43(3), 377-391. https://doi.org/10.1177/00027649921955326
Star, S. L., & Ruhleder, K. (1996). Steps toward an ecology of infrastructure: Design and access for large information spaces. Information Systems Research, 7(1), 111-134.
Stoler, A. L., & De Gruyter. (2018). Along the Archival Grain : Epistemic Anxieties and Colonial Common Sense. Princeton University Press. https://doi.org/10.1515/9781400835478
Mattern, S. (2018, November). Maintenance and Care. Places Journal. source
Image Reference
The Registry of Sarees Archives.
Written by Lakthing Mayurchon Muinao
Lakthing, is a researcher at The Registry of Sarees. She is drawn in the intersection of culture with material studies; politics of display and representation; and textile studies. She hopes to pen down her observation and ponder them through these journals.
Leave a comment